The defendant must breach the duty of care by failing to act as a reasonable person would under similar circumstances. This breach can involve an action or a failure to act. In breach of duty, defendant is only liable in reasonably foreseeable circumstances and not in exceptional circumstances. In the case of
Blyth v. Birmingham Waterworks Company, the defendants, Birmingham Waterworks Company, had been incorporated by statute for the purpose of supplying Birmingham with water. The Company had installed a fireplug into the hydrant near the plaintiff’s house and the plug failed during a severe frost in winter causing a flood and damage to the plaintiff’s house. The Court held that the severe frost was something that the Company could not have anticipated and Birmingham had not seen such a cold winter in a long time. This rendered the event unforeseeable and therefore, Birmingham Waterworks Company could only have been negligent if they had failed to do what a reasonable person would do in the circumstances.