Principle: In contract law, the principle of “free consent” ensures that the parties have agreed to the same thing in the same sense without any force, fraud, misrepresentation, or undue influence. A contract is not valid if consent is obtained by coercion.
Fact: A threatens to file a false criminal case against B unless B sells his car to A at half its market price. B agrees and sells the car.
Question: Is the contract valid?
Options: A. Yes, because B agreed to sell the car. B. No, because consent was obtained under coercion. C. Yes, because no physical harm was done. D. No, because B could have refused.
Answer: B. No, because consent was obtained under coercion.
Explanation: Under Section 15 of the Indian Contract Act, coercion includes threatening to bring a false case. Consent obtained this way is not free, making the contract voidable.
Question 2
Principle: A contract entered without consideration is generally void unless it falls under exceptions. Consideration is an essential element of a valid contract.
Fact: A promises to give ₹10,000 to his nephew B out of love and affection without any reciprocal promise.
Question: Is the promise enforceable?
Options: A. Yes, it is a valid contract. B. No, because there is no consideration. C. Yes, because the promise is between close relatives. D. No, because it is illegal.
Answer: B. No, because there is no consideration.
Explanation: A gratuitous promise without consideration is not enforceable unless made in writing and registered (as per exception under Section 25). Here, it’s not mentioned.
Question 3
Principle: An agreement with an unlawful object is void. A contract with an illegal objective is not enforceable in law.
Fact: A hires B to smuggle goods across the border for ₹50,000. B completes the task but A refuses to pay.
Question: Can B sue A for payment?
Options: A. Yes, because the contract was completed. B. No, because the object was unlawful. C. Yes, because A is unjustly enriched. D. No, because it was a verbal contract.
Answer: B. No, because the object was unlawful.
Explanation: Agreements with unlawful objectives are void ab initio, and courts will not enforce them or help recover under them.
Question 4
Principle: A proposal must be accepted unequivocally to result in a contract. Conditional acceptance is not a valid acceptance.
Fact: A offers to sell his bike to B for ₹20,000. B says, “I accept, if you also include the helmet.”
Question: Is there a valid acceptance?
Options: A. Yes, as B has accepted the main offer. B. No, because it is a counter-offer. C. Yes, because the condition is minor. D. No, because the offer was revoked.
Answer: B. No, because it is a counter-offer.
Explanation: A conditional acceptance amounts to a counter-offer, not acceptance. Hence, no valid contract is formed.
Question 5
Principle: Communication of revocation must reach the other party before acceptance. Revocation is effective only when it is communicated before acceptance.
Fact: A offers to sell land to B. Before B accepts, A sends a revocation letter which reaches B after B had already posted his acceptance.
Question: Is the revocation valid?
Options: A. Yes, because A intended to revoke. B. No, because B already accepted. C. Yes, because the letter was sent. D. No, because it was not signed.
Answer: B. No, because B already accepted.
Explanation: According to the postal rule, acceptance is complete when posted. Revocation must reach before acceptance is posted.
Question 6
Principle: Agreements in restraint of trade are void. Every agreement restraining anyone from exercising a lawful profession, trade or business is void.
Fact: X, a software engineer, agrees not to work for any other company for 5 years after leaving ABC Ltd.
Question: Is this agreement valid?
Options: A. Yes, as X agreed voluntarily. B. No, as it restrains trade. C. Yes, because it’s a private agreement. D. No, because it’s not in writing.
Answer: B. No, as it restrains trade.
Explanation: Section 27 of the Indian Contract Act makes such clauses void unless reasonable and justified (e.g., protecting trade secrets).
Question 7
Principle: Only parties to a contract can sue upon it. A stranger to the contract cannot sue.
Fact: A contracts with B to deliver goods to C. A fails to deliver.
Question: Can C sue A?
Options: A. Yes, because the contract was for C’s benefit. B. No, because C is a stranger to the contract. C. Yes, because B is also liable. D. No, because C did not accept.
Answer: B. No, because C is a stranger to the contract.
Explanation: Under the privity of contract rule, only parties to the contract have the right to sue.
Question 8
Principle: Silence is not fraud unless there is a duty to speak. Mere silence does not amount to fraud unless the circumstances impose a duty to speak.
Fact: A sells a house to B but doesn’t disclose that it is prone to flooding.
Question: Is A guilty of fraud?
Options: A. Yes, as he hid information. B. No, because B should have investigated. C. No, unless A had a duty to speak. D. Yes, because silence always amounts to fraud.
Answer: C. No, unless A had a duty to speak.
Explanation: Fraud requires active concealment or a duty to disclose. Mere silence, in absence of such a duty, is not fraud.
Question 9
Principle: An agreement made under a mistake of fact is void. Bilateral mistake of essential fact renders a contract void.
Fact: A agrees to sell B a cargo ship thinking it’s in the harbor, but it had already sunk.
Question: Is the contract valid?
Options: A. Yes, because both agreed. B. No, because the subject no longer exists. C. Yes, because A didn’t know. D. No, because the price was not paid.
Answer: B. No, because the subject no longer exists.
Explanation: There’s a bilateral mistake regarding the existence of the subject matter. Such contracts are void under Section 20.
Question 10
Principle: A minor is incompetent to contract. A contract with a minor is void ab initio.
Fact: A 17-year-old boy enters a contract to buy a bike on EMI.
Question: Is the contract enforceable?
Options: A. Yes, if he pays regularly. B. No, because he is a minor. C. Yes, because the seller agreed. D. No, because it is illegal.
Answer: B. No, because he is a minor.
Explanation: A minor cannot enter into a contract. Such a contract is void and cannot be enforced by or against the minor.