Learn in a Minute: Rejection of a Plaint under Order 7 Rule 11 of Civil Procedure Code
SH
Shruti chauhan7 min readRejection of Plaint under Order VII Rule 11 CPC
What is a Plaint?
A plaint is the written statement of claim with which a plaintiff starts a civil suit. Under Section 26 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC), every suit is instituted by presenting a plaint, which sets out the facts, the cause of action and the relief claimed. For the steps involved, see how to file a plaint and the institution of a suit.
Order VII of the CPC deals with plaints. Rules 1 to 8 say what a plaint must contain. Rule 10 deals with returning a plaint filed in the wrong court. Rule 11 lists the cases in which a plaint must be rejected, and Rules 12 and 13 deal with what follows a rejection.
Rejection under Rule 11 lets a court end a suit at the threshold, without a trial, when the plaint itself shows a fatal defect. It saves the court's time and spares defendants from meritless litigation.
Essential Elements of a Plaint
Order VII Rules 1 to 8 set out what every plaint must contain. Missing particulars can lead to the plaint being returned for amendment, and, where the defect goes to the root, to rejection.
- Rule 1, particulars: the name of the court; the name, description and place of residence of the plaintiff and the defendant; a statement if either is a minor or of unsound mind; the facts constituting the cause of action and when it arose; the facts showing the court's jurisdiction; the relief claimed; any set-off allowed; and a statement of the value of the subject matter for jurisdiction and court fees.
- Rule 2, money suits: where the plaintiff seeks money, the plaint must state the precise amount claimed (Rule 2A covers claims for interest).
- Rule 3, immovable property: where the subject matter is immovable property, the plaint must describe it well enough to identify it, such as by boundaries or survey numbers.
- Rule 4, representative capacity: where the plaintiff sues in a representative capacity, the plaint must show the plaintiff's actual interest and the steps taken to sue in that capacity.
- Rule 5, defendant's interest: the plaint must show that the defendant is or claims to be interested in the subject matter, and is liable to answer the claim.
For example, in a suit to evict a tenant, the plaint should identify the property, state the tenancy and the ground for eviction, show why the court has jurisdiction, value the suit, and ask specifically for possession and any arrears of rent.
Grounds for Rejection under Order 7 Rule 11
Order VII Rule 11 says a plaint "shall be rejected" in six cases, labelled (a) to (f). The list is exhaustive: a plaint cannot be rejected under Rule 11 for any other reason. Misjoinder or non-joinder of parties, for example, is not a ground for rejection, since Order I Rule 9 says no suit fails for that reason alone; see misjoinder and non-joinder of parties.
(a) No cause of action
The plaint must disclose a cause of action: a set of facts which, if proved, would entitle the plaintiff to the relief claimed. If it does not, it must be rejected. A suit for breach of contract that alleges no breach, or a damages claim that shows no link between the defendant's act and the harm, would fail here. The test is whether the plaint discloses a cause of action, not whether the plaintiff is likely to win.
(b) Undervaluation
Where the relief claimed is undervalued, the court must first ask the plaintiff to correct the valuation within a fixed time. Only if the plaintiff fails to do so is the plaint rejected. For example, a plaintiff might value a suit for possession of property worth ₹1 crore at ₹10 lakh, to pay lower court fees or to file in a lower court.
(c) Insufficient stamp
Where the relief is properly valued but the court fee paid is too low, the court must again give the plaintiff time to make up the shortfall. The plaint is rejected only if the stamp paper is not supplied within that time. The proviso to Rule 11 says the court will not extend the time for (b) or (c) unless the plaintiff was prevented by exceptional circumstances, and refusing to extend it would cause grave injustice.
(d) Barred by law
The plaint is rejected where the suit "appears from the statement in the plaint" to be barred by any law, such as the Limitation Act or a statute that bars civil suits. The bar must be clear from the plaint's own averments. A suit that is plainly time-barred on the dates the plaintiff gives can be rejected; a question that needs evidence cannot be decided under this clause. Res judicata usually falls in the second category, because it needs the earlier pleadings and judgment.
(e) Not filed in duplicate
The plaint must be filed in duplicate. A plaint filed in a single copy is liable to be rejected. This clause was added by the CPC (Amendment) Act, 1999, which came into force in 2002.
(f) Non-compliance with Rule 9
Order VII Rule 9 requires the plaintiff to file copies of the plaint for service on each defendant, and to pay the process fee, within the time the court fixes. If the plaintiff fails to do so, the plaint is rejected. This clause was also added by the 1999 Amendment.
Grounds under Order VII Rule 11
| Clause | Ground | Example | Can it be cured? |
| (a) | Plaint does not disclose a cause of action | Suit on a contract that alleges no breach |
Procedure and Stage of Filing the Application
A plaint can be rejected under Order VII Rule 11 at any stage of the suit, and the court can act even without an application.
- At any stage: in Saleem Bhai v State of Maharashtra (2003), the Supreme Court held that the power can be exercised at any stage: before the plaint is registered, after summons is issued, or at any time before the trial ends. The defendant does not have to file a written statement first.
- On the court's own motion: Rule 11 says the plaint "shall be rejected". It places a duty on the court, so the court can reject a defective plaint even if no one applies.
- On the defendant's application: usually, the defendant files an application under Order VII Rule 11, ideally at the earliest opportunity. The plaintiff is heard before the court decides.
- Recording reasons: under Order VII Rule 12, a judge who rejects a plaint must record an order to that effect, with reasons.
The court must also reject the plaint as a whole or not at all. In Madhav Prasad Aggarwal v Axis Bank (2019), the Supreme Court held that a plaint cannot be rejected against only some defendants, or for only some reliefs. If any part survives, the whole suit goes to trial.
The Court Reads Only the Plaint
On an application under Order VII Rule 11, the court looks only at the plaint and the documents filed with it. It does not look at the defence.
- Averments taken as true: the court assumes for this purpose that everything the plaint says is true, and asks whether, on that assumption, the plaint discloses a cause of action or shows the suit is barred.
- The written statement is irrelevant: in Saleem Bhai, the Court held that the defendant's pleas in the written statement are wholly irrelevant at this stage.
- The plaint read as a whole: the court must read the plaint meaningfully and as a whole, not pick out isolated sentences. A plaint that discloses a cause of action when read fully cannot be rejected because one paragraph is weak.
- No mini-trial: disputed questions of fact, and points that need evidence, cannot be decided under Rule 11. They must go to trial.
- Clever drafting does not save a plaint: in T. Arivandandam v T.V. Satyapal (1977), the Supreme Court said that where clever drafting creates only an illusion of a cause of action, the court should "nip it in the bud" at the first hearing.
What Happens If a Plaint is Rejected?
When a plaint is rejected, the suit ends. The plaintiff then has two options: appeal, or file a fresh plaint.
A deemed decree
Section 2(2) of the CPC says a decree "shall be deemed to include the rejection of a plaint". So an order rejecting a plaint is treated as a decree, even though no trial was held and the merits were not decided.
Appeal
Because it is a deemed decree, an order rejecting a plaint can be appealed as a decree under Section 96, to the court that hears first appeals. An order refusing to reject a plaint is not a decree, and generally cannot be appealed; it can be challenged in revision or in the appeal against the final decree.
Fresh suit (Order VII Rule 13)
Order VII Rule 13 says the rejection of a plaint on any ground in Rule 11 does not, by itself, stop the plaintiff from presenting a fresh plaint on the same cause of action. The plaintiff can cure the defect and file again, as long as the new suit is within limitation and not otherwise barred. Rejection is not a decision on the merits, so res judicata does not apply to it.
For example, if a plaint is rejected under clause (c) because the court fee was not paid in time, the plaintiff can file a fresh plaint with the correct fee, provided the suit is still within limitation.
Rejection vs Return vs Dismissal
Rejection, return and dismissal all end a suit in a particular court, but for different reasons and with different consequences. Rejection is for a defect in the plaint; return is for filing in the wrong court; dismissal comes after trial, or for the plaintiff's default.
| Basis | Rejection (O7 R11) | Return (O7 R10) | Dismissal |
| Reason | A defect in clauses (a)–(f) | Court lacks jurisdiction |
The distinction also decides how an order can be challenged. Rejection is a deemed decree, so a full first appeal lies. Return of a plaint is an appealable order under Order XLIII. An order refusing to reject a plaint is only an interlocutory order, with no appeal.
Leading Cases
Five Supreme Court decisions set out most of the law on Order VII Rule 11.
| Case | Year | Held |
| T. Arivandandam v T.V. Satyapal | 1977 | Clever drafting that creates an illusion of a cause of action should be nipped in the bud |
| Saleem Bhai v State of Maharashtra |
FAQs
What are the grounds for rejection of a plaint?
Order VII Rule 11 lists six: (a) no cause of action; (b) undervaluation not corrected in time; (c) insufficient stamp not made good in time; (d) the suit appears from the plaint to be barred by law; (e) the plaint is not filed in duplicate; and (f) the plaintiff fails to comply with Order VII Rule 9.
Is rejection of a plaint appealable?
Yes. Under Section 2(2) of the CPC, the rejection of a plaint is deemed to be a decree, so it can be appealed under Section 96, like any other decree. An order refusing to reject a plaint is not a decree and is generally not appealable.
Can a fresh suit be filed after rejection?
Yes. Order VII Rule 13 says rejection does not, by itself, stop the plaintiff from presenting a fresh plaint on the same cause of action. The new plaint must cure the defect and be filed within limitation.
Can the court reject a plaint on its own?
Yes. Rule 11 says the plaint "shall be rejected" in the listed cases, which places a duty on the court. It can reject a defective plaint on its own motion, without waiting for the defendant to apply, after hearing the plaintiff.
At what stage can Order 7 Rule 11 be invoked?
At any stage of the suit: before the plaint is registered, after summons is issued, or at any time before the trial ends, as held in Saleem Bhai v State of Maharashtra (2003). The defendant does not need to file a written statement first.
Subscribe for updates
Join 10,000+ subscribers.
SH
Shruti chauhan
Contributing author
Have a doubt about this?Ask Doubts

