Strict Liability under Tort Law: Definition, Elements and, Defences
What is the Meaning of Strict Liability?
Elements of Strict Liability
(2) Escape of dangerous thing
(3) Non-natural use of land
Important Cases on Elements of Strict Liability
Crowhurst v. Amersham Burial Board: The defendant had planted a yew tree on their property but the tree was planted very close to the plaintiff’s property. Gradually, the tree’s branch grew over the fence and protruded into the plaintiff’s ground. A few leaves fell on the other side of the fence and the plaintiff’s horse ate some and died from poisoning. The plaintiff brought an action against the defendant for damages for the death of his horse. This claim was not successful as the defendant was not making non-natural use of his land.
Read v. Lyons: In this case, the claimant was employed by the defendant in his factory which made explosives for the Ministry of Supply. While on inspection, an explosion occurred that injured the claimant. While there was no evidence of negligence on the part of the defendant, the judge held that the case was governed by the rule in Rylands v Fletcher and therefore, strict liability would apply. The Court of Appeal then reversed this decision as escape of the hazardous matter from land is an essential element of strict liability and there was no escape in this case. Besides, there was no non-natural use of the land either.
Defences to Strict Liability under Tort Law

- Act of God: Two important cases i.e. Rylands v. Fletcher and Nichols v. Marshland talk about Act of God and define it as an event wherein the circumstances are beyond human foresight. As these events happen because of supernatural forces and without any human intervention, no one can be held liable for them.
- Fault of the Plaintiff: If the damage is caused by plaintiff’s own default or wrongdoing then the rule of strict liability can’t be applied. In the case of Ponting v. Noakes, the plaintiff’s horse trespassed into the defendant’s property and ate poisonous leaves. The Court held that the damage was caused by plaintiff’s own fault as he let his horse go into the property of defendant. Therefore, under such circumstances the defendant cannot be held liable.
- Statutory authority: If the damage has been caused by an act which the legislature has authorized, the rule of strict liability can’t be applied.
- Consent of the Plaintiff: If the plaintiff has consented to the accumulation of a dangerous thing on the defendant’s land, then he cannot complain about the consequences. This is similar to the rule of volenti non fit injuria.

