Legal Reasoning Questions to Practice for CLAT 2020
Legal Reasoning Questions to Practice for CLAT 2020
.docxpressoPlugin { font-size: 83.35%; } .h5p_layout { box-sizing: content-box !important; } .h5p_layout *{ float: none; text-align: initial; box-sizing: border-box; } /*to make sure that floating elements are always inside the document bounds*/ .h5p_layout:after { content: " "; display: block; height: 0; clear: both; visibility: hidden; } /* a default layout for documents without maste styles */ .h5p_default_layout { margin-top: 3.6rem; margin-left: 8.50464rem; margin-bottom: 3.6rem; margin-right: 8.50464rem; writing-mode: lr-tb; } /*hack for IE */ wbr:after { content: "\00200B"; } /*hack to get some extra top margin for anchors if needed*/ .h5p_layout span[id^="_Toc"]{ padding-top: 10px; margin-top: -10px; } /* Remove unwanted numbering styles */ .h5p_layout .removeNumbering:before{ content: initial !important; display: none; all: initial !important; } /* give zero default top and bottom paddings for paragraphs*/ .h5p_layout p { color: #000000; line-height: 1; margin-top: 0; margin-bottom: 0; } .h5p_layout span { color: #000000; font-weight: normal; } .h5p_layout span.dropcap { color: inherit; font-family: inherit !important; } .h5p_layout h1, .h5p_layout h2, .h5p_layout h3, .h5p_layout h4, .h5p_layout h5, .h5p_layout h6 { margin-top: 0; margin-bottom: 0; font-family: inherit; font-weight: 500; line-height: 1; color: inherit; } /* give zero default top and bottom paddings for paragraphs in tables*/ .h5p_layout table p { margin-top: 0; margin-bottom: 0; } .h5p_layout ul, .h5p_layout ol { list-style-type: none; margin-top: 0; margin-bottom: 0.5em; padding-left: 0; } .h5p_layout ul li, .h5p_layout ol li { list-style-type: none; margin-top: 0; margin-bottom: 0.5em; } .h5p_layout li p { margin-top: 0; margin-bottom: 0; } .h5p_layout table { border: none; } .h5p_layout td { vertical-align: top; border: none; } .h5p_layout th { vertical-align: top; border: none; } .h5p_layout div { margin-bottom: 10pt; } .h5p_layout img { margin: 0; padding: 0; } .h5p_layout ul ul { margin-top: 0; margin-bottom: 0; } .h5p_layout li { margin-top: 0; margin-bottom: 0; list-style-type: none !important; } .h5p_layout ul, .h5p_layout ol { list-style-type: none !important; } .h5p_layout td[data-sorting] p:before, .h5p_layout th[data-sorting] p:before { content: ' '; padding-right: 16px; background: url(); background-position: left center; background-repeat: no-repeat; } .sortDecorator { border-bottom: 3px solid #b70000 !important; } /* This is a spacial class designed to remove unwanted bullets when a li has ul as its first child*/ .h5p_layout .removeBullet:before { content: none !important; } /*responsive tables*/ .h5p_layout div.dxoResponsiveTable{ margin: 0 !important; padding: 0 !important; overflow-x: auto !important; overflow-y: hidden; } /* chart tooltips */ .c3-tooltip-container td.name { white-space: nowrap; } /* External services*/ .h5p_layout iframe { resize: vertical; border: 1px solid #fff; } .h5p_layout div.youtube { position:relative; padding-bottom:56.25%; height:0; overflow:hidden; background-color: transparent; } .h5p_layout div.youtube iframe { resize: none; position:absolute; top:0; left:0; width:100%; height:100%; } div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P1 {border-top: none !important;border-left: none !important;border-bottom: 0.0138in solid #4F81BD !important;border-right: none !important;padding-top: 0in !important;padding-left: 0in !important;padding-bottom: 0.0555in !important;padding-right: 0in !important;margin-bottom: 0.2083in !important;line-height: 1 !important;break-before: page !important;text-align: center !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P1 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Cambria;color: #17365D;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;font-size: 26pt;hyphenate: false;background-color: #FFFFFF;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P2 {border-top: none !important;border-left: none !important;border-bottom: 0.0138in solid #4F81BD !important;border-right: none !important;padding-top: 0in !important;padding-left: 0in !important;padding-bottom: 0.0555in !important;padding-right: 0in !important;margin-bottom: 0.2083in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: center !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P2 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Cambria;color: #17365D;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;font-size: 26pt;hyphenate: false;background-color: #FFFFFF;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P3 {border-top: none !important;border-left: none !important;border-bottom: 0.0138in solid #4F81BD !important;border-right: none !important;padding-top: 0in !important;padding-left: 0in !important;padding-bottom: 0.0555in !important;padding-right: 0in !important;margin-bottom: 0.2083in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: center !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P3 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Cambria;color: #17365D;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;font-size: 26pt;hyphenate: false;background-color: #FFFFFF;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P4 {text-align: justify !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P4 span {hyphenate: false;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;background-color: #FFFFFF;text-decoration: single;text-decoration: underline;text-decoration-style: solid;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P5 {text-align: justify !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T6 {color: #000000 !important;letter-spacing: 0.0034in !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;text-decoration: single !important;text-decoration: underline !important;text-decoration-style: solid !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T7 {color: #000000 !important;letter-spacing: 0.0034in !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T8 {color: #000000 !important;letter-spacing: 0.0034in !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;text-decoration: single !important;text-decoration: underline !important;text-decoration-style: solid !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P9 {text-align: justify !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P9 span {hyphenate: false;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;background-color: #FFFFFF;text-decoration: single;text-decoration: underline;text-decoration-style: solid;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P10 {margin-top: 0.0694in !important;margin-bottom: 0.0694in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: justify !important;margin-top: 0.2083in !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;line-height: 1.15 !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P10 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;font-family: Calibri;color: #2B2B2B;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P11 {margin-top: 0.0694in !important;margin-bottom: 0.0694in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: justify !important;margin-top: 0.2083in !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;line-height: 1.15 !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P11 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;font-family: Calibri;color: #2B2B2B;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P12 {margin-top: 0.0694in !important;margin-bottom: 0.0694in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: justify !important;margin-top: 0.2083in !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;line-height: 1.15 !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P12 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;font-family: Calibri;color: #2B2B2B;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P13 {margin-top: 0.0694in !important;margin-bottom: 0.0694in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: justify !important;margin-top: 0.2083in !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;line-height: 1.15 !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P13 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;font-family: Calibri;color: #2B2B2B;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P14 {margin-top: 0.0694in !important;margin-bottom: 0.0694in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: justify !important;margin-top: 0.2083in !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;line-height: 1.15 !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P14 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;font-family: Calibri;color: #2B2B2B;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P15 {margin-top: 0.0694in !important;margin-bottom: 0.0694in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: justify !important;margin-top: 0.2083in !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;line-height: 1.15 !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P15 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;font-family: Calibri;color: #2B2B2B;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P16 {margin-top: 0.0694in !important;margin-bottom: 0.0694in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: justify !important;margin-top: 0in !important;margin-bottom: 0.1562in !important;line-height: 1.15 !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T17 {font-family: Calibri !important;color: #000000 !important;letter-spacing: 0.0034in !important;font-size: 11pt !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T18 {font-family: Calibri !important;color: #000000 !important;letter-spacing: 0.0034in !important;font-size: 11pt !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T19 {font-family: Calibri !important;color: #000000 !important;letter-spacing: 0.0034in !important;font-size: 11pt !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T20 {font-family: Calibri !important;color: #000000 !important;letter-spacing: 0.0034in !important;font-size: 11pt !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T21 {font-family: Calibri !important;color: #000000 !important;letter-spacing: 0.0034in !important;font-size: 11pt !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T22 {font-family: Calibri !important;color: #000000 !important;letter-spacing: 0.0034in !important;font-size: 11pt !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T23 {font-family: Calibri !important;color: #000000 !important;letter-spacing: 0.0034in !important;font-size: 11pt !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P24 {margin-top: 0.0694in !important;margin-bottom: 0.0694in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: justify !important;margin-top: 0in !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;line-height: 1.15 !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P24 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;font-family: Calibri;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;font-size: 11pt;background-color: #FFFFFF;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P25 {margin-top: 0.0694in !important;margin-bottom: 0.0694in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: justify !important;margin-top: 0in !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;line-height: 1.15 !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P25 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;font-family: Calibri;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;font-size: 11pt;background-color: #FFFFFF;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P26 {margin-top: 0.0694in !important;margin-bottom: 0.0694in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: justify !important;margin-top: 0in !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;line-height: 1.15 !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T27 {font-family: Calibri !important;color: #000000 !important;letter-spacing: 0.0034in !important;font-size: 11pt !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T28 {font-family: Calibri !important;color: #000000 !important;letter-spacing: 0.0034in !important;font-size: 11pt !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T29 {font-family: Calibri !important;color: #000000 !important;letter-spacing: 0.0034in !important;font-size: 11pt !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T30 {font-family: Calibri !important;color: #000000 !important;letter-spacing: 0.0034in !important;font-size: 11pt !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T31 {font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T32 {font-family: Calibri !important;color: #000000 !important;letter-spacing: 0.0034in !important;font-size: 11pt !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P33 {margin-top: 0.0694in !important;margin-bottom: 0.0694in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: justify !important;margin-top: 0in !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;line-height: 1.15 !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P33 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;font-family: Calibri;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;font-size: 11pt;background-color: #FFFFFF;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P34 {margin-top: 0.0694in !important;margin-bottom: 0.0694in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: justify !important;margin-top: 0in !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;line-height: 1.15 !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P34 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;font-family: Calibri;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;font-size: 11pt;background-color: #FFFFFF;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P35 {margin-top: 0.0694in !important;margin-bottom: 0.0694in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: justify !important;margin-top: 0in !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;line-height: 1.15 !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P35 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;font-family: Calibri;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;font-size: 11pt;background-color: #FFFFFF;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P36 {margin-top: 0.0694in !important;margin-bottom: 0.0694in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: justify !important;margin-top: 0in !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;line-height: 1.15 !important;margin-left: 0.5in !important;text-indent: -0.5in !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P36 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;font-family: Calibri;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;font-size: 11pt;background-color: #FFFFFF;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P37 {margin-top: 0.0694in !important;margin-bottom: 0.0694in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: justify !important;margin-top: 0in !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;line-height: 1.15 !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P37 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;font-family: Calibri;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;font-size: 11pt;background-color: #FFFFFF;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P38 {margin-top: 0.0694in !important;margin-bottom: 0.0694in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: justify !important;margin-top: 0in !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;line-height: 1.15 !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P38 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;font-family: Calibri;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;font-size: 11pt;background-color: #FFFFFF;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P39 {margin-top: 0.0694in !important;margin-bottom: 0.0694in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: justify !important;margin-top: 0in !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;line-height: 1.15 !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P39 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;font-family: Calibri;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;font-size: 11pt;background-color: #FFFFFF;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P40 {margin-top: 0.0694in !important;margin-bottom: 0.0694in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: justify !important;margin-top: 0in !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;line-height: 1.15 !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P40 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;font-family: Calibri;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;font-size: 11pt;background-color: #FFFFFF;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P41 {margin-top: 0.0694in !important;margin-bottom: 0.0694in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: justify !important;margin-top: 0in !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;line-height: 1.15 !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P41 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;font-family: Calibri;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;font-size: 11pt;background-color: #FFFFFF;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P42 {margin-top: 0.0694in !important;margin-bottom: 0.0694in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: justify !important;margin-top: 0in !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;line-height: 1.15 !important;margin-left: 0.5in !important;text-indent: -0.5in !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P42 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;font-family: Calibri;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;font-size: 11pt;background-color: #FFFFFF;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P43 {margin-top: 0.0694in !important;margin-bottom: 0.0694in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: justify !important;margin-top: 0in !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;line-height: 1.15 !important;margin-left: 0.5in !important;text-indent: -0.5in !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P43 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;font-family: Calibri;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;font-size: 11pt;background-color: #FFFFFF;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P44 {margin-top: 0.0694in !important;margin-bottom: 0.0694in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: justify !important;margin-top: 0in !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;line-height: 1.15 !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P44 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;font-family: Calibri;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;font-size: 11pt;background-color: #FFFFFF;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P45 {margin-top: 0.0694in !important;margin-bottom: 0.0694in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: justify !important;margin-top: 0in !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;line-height: 1.15 !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P45 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;font-family: Calibri;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;font-size: 11pt;background-color: #FFFFFF;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P46 {margin-top: 0.0694in !important;margin-bottom: 0.0694in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: justify !important;margin-top: 0in !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;line-height: 1.15 !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P46 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;font-family: Calibri;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;font-size: 11pt;background-color: #FFFFFF;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P47 {font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P47 span {hyphenate: false;text-decoration: single;text-decoration: underline;text-decoration-style: solid;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P48 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P48 span {hyphenate: false;color: #2B2B2B;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P49 {text-align: justify !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P49 span {hyphenate: false;color: #2B2B2B;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P50 {text-align: justify !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P50 span {hyphenate: false;color: #2B2B2B;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P51 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T52 {color: #2B2B2B !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T53 {color: #2B2B2B !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P54 {text-align: justify !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P54 span {hyphenate: false;color: #2B2B2B;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P55 {margin-top: 0.0694in !important;margin-bottom: 0.0694in !important;line-height: 1 !important;text-align: justify !important;margin-top: 0in !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;line-height: 1.15 !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T56 {font-family: Calibri !important;color: #000000 !important;letter-spacing: 0.0034in !important;font-size: 11pt !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T57 {font-family: Calibri !important;color: #000000 !important;letter-spacing: 0.0034in !important;font-size: 11pt !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T58 {font-family: Calibri !important;color: #000000 !important;letter-spacing: 0.0034in !important;font-size: 11pt !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T59 {font-family: Calibri !important;color: #000000 !important;letter-spacing: 0.0034in !important;font-size: 11pt !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T60 {font-family: Calibri !important;color: #000000 !important;letter-spacing: 0.0034in !important;font-size: 11pt !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T61 {font-family: Calibri !important;color: #000000 !important;letter-spacing: 0.0034in !important;font-size: 11pt !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P62 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P62 span {hyphenate: false;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P63 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P63 span {hyphenate: false;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P64 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P64 span {hyphenate: false;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P65 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P65 span {hyphenate: false;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P66 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P66 span {hyphenate: false;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P67 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P67 span {hyphenate: false;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P68 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P68 span {hyphenate: false;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P69 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P69 span {hyphenate: false;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P70 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P70 span {hyphenate: false;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P71 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P71 span {hyphenate: false;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P72 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P72 span {hyphenate: false;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P73 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P73 span {hyphenate: false;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P74 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P74 span {hyphenate: false;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P75 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P75 span {hyphenate: false;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P76 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P76 span {hyphenate: false;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P77 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P77 span {hyphenate: false;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P78 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P78 span {hyphenate: false;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P79 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T80 {font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T81 {font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T82 {font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P83 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P83 span {hyphenate: false;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P84 {text-align: justify !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P84 span {hyphenate: false;color: #2B2B2B;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P85 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P85 span {hyphenate: false;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;background-color: #FFFFFF;text-decoration: single;text-decoration: underline;text-decoration-style: solid;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P86 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P86 span {hyphenate: false;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;background-color: #FFFFFF;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P87 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P87 span {hyphenate: false;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;background-color: #FFFFFF;text-decoration: single;text-decoration: underline;text-decoration-style: solid;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P88 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P88 span {hyphenate: false;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;background-color: #FFFFFF;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P89 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P89 span {hyphenate: false;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;background-color: #FFFFFF;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P90 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P90 span {hyphenate: false;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;background-color: #FFFFFF;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P91 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P91 span {hyphenate: false;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;background-color: #FFFFFF;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P92 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P92 span {hyphenate: false;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;background-color: #FFFFFF;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P93 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P93 span {hyphenate: false;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;background-color: #FFFFFF;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P94 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P94 span {hyphenate: false;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;background-color: #FFFFFF;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P95 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P95 span {hyphenate: false;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;background-color: #FFFFFF;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P96 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P96 span {hyphenate: false;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;background-color: #FFFFFF;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P97 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P97 span {hyphenate: false;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;background-color: #FFFFFF;text-decoration: single;text-decoration: underline;text-decoration-style: solid;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P98 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P98 span {hyphenate: false;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;background-color: #FFFFFF;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P99 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P99 span {hyphenate: false;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;background-color: #FFFFFF;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P100 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P100 span {hyphenate: false;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;background-color: #FFFFFF;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P101 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P101 span {hyphenate: false;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;background-color: #FFFFFF;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P102 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P102 span {hyphenate: false;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;background-color: #FFFFFF;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P103 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P103 span {hyphenate: false;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;background-color: #FFFFFF;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P104 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P104 span {hyphenate: false;color: #000000;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;background-color: #FFFFFF;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P105 {text-align: justify !important;margin-bottom: 0in !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T106 {color: #000000 !important;letter-spacing: 0.0034in !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.T107 {color: #000000 !important;letter-spacing: 0.0034in !important;background-color: #FFFFFF !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.Normal {font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.Normal span {hyphenate: false;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.DefaultParagraphFont {font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.NormalWeb {margin-top: 0.0694in !important;margin-bottom: 0.0694in !important;line-height: 1 !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.NormalWeb span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.Hyperlink {color: #0000FF !important;text-decoration: single !important;text-decoration: underline !important;text-decoration-style: solid !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.Title {border-top: none !important;border-left: none !important;border-bottom: 0.0138in solid #4F81BD !important;border-right: none !important;padding-top: 0in !important;padding-left: 0in !important;padding-bottom: 0.0555in !important;padding-right: 0in !important;margin-bottom: 0.2083in !important;line-height: 1 !important;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.Title span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Cambria;color: #17365D;letter-spacing: 0.0034in;font-size: 26pt;hyphenate: false;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce span.TitleChar {font-family: Cambria !important;color: #17365D !important;letter-spacing: 0.0034in !important;font-size: 26pt !important;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce div {font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P5 span {hyphenate: false;hyphenate: false;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P51 span {hyphenate: false;hyphenate: false;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P79 span {hyphenate: false;hyphenate: false;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P105 span {hyphenate: false;hyphenate: false;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P16 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P26 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p.P55 span {hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;hyphenate: false;font-family: Times New Roman;font-size: 12pt;hyphenate: false;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce table {margin-left: 0in;border-collapse: collapse;writing-mode: lr-tb;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce table tr {height: 0in;keep-together: auto;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce table td, table th {background-color: transparent;vertical-align: top;wrap-option: wrap;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p {keep-with-next: auto;keep-together: auto;widows: 2;orphans: 2;break-before: auto;border: none;text-align: left;writing-mode: lr-tb;margin-bottom: 0.1388in;line-height: 1.15;background-color: transparent;font-size: 11pt;} div#h5p_6a7c0da8141ce p span {font-family: Calibri;font-weight: normal;font-style: normal;text-transform: none;font-variant: normal;text-shadow: none;letter-spacing: normal;font-size: 11pt;background-color: transparent;text-decoration: none;text-decoration-color: font-color;language: en;country: IN;hyphenate: true;}
Legal Reasoning Questions for CLAT 2020 Read the passage given below and answer the questions that follow- Passage IHow can we measure crime? The simplest answer would be the official crime statistics. But in a country such as India, dependence on these figures is misleading as police have a regrettable tendency to downgrade crimes or discourage complainant to leave police stations without filing a complaint. Underreporting and non-reporting of criminal cases, which have been a huge problem in all Indian states, totally distort the crime scenario. Despite being aware that allowing mandatory or free registration of cases would certainly inflate crime statistics, Rajasthan became the first Indian state almost a year ago, when the Chief Minister, Ashok Gahlot, demonstrated remarkable political courage by removing the obstacles in mandatory registration of cases. By all accounts, it has been a bold initiative signaling seminal contribution to police reforms in the country.The reports of various police commissions and available literature on police reforms clearly indicate that non-reporting or non-registration of cases is a widespread and serious problem across India. Being the first point of contact with the criminal justice delivery system, a police station, headed by a Station House Officer (SHO), is the most important unit of police functioning. It is engaged with multiple functions such as the registration of crimes through the First Information Report (FIR) and their investigations, handling of various law and order situations, patrolling, and ensuring safety and security in its jurisdiction. However, what gives the power and visibility to a police station and its SHO is the registration or rather the non-registration of cases.Under Section 154 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC), registration of an FIR is mandatory if the complaint discloses that a cognizable offence has been committed. Although, a preliminary inquiry may be conducted to ensure the nature of an offence, however the scope of such an inquiry is not to confirm the authenticity or otherwise of the complaint but only to ascertain whether it was cognizable complaint of a crime. In theory, the SHO of a police station cannot avoid registration of the FIR and, action has to be taken against those SHOs who do not immediately register the FIR for a cognizable offence. But it is rarely followed in practice.Police stations across the country are notorious for not registering cases as police personnel are aware that their performance is judged on the basis of this information, and they have developed various informal mechanisms to circumvent this legal imposition. One cannot deny that police professionals are overworked and unappreciated. Since registration of cases increases the burden as well as the crime statistics of a police station, an SHO has a vested interest in discouraging non-registration of cases in his jurisdiction. Police legitimacy and public safety are closely related to each other. If the police department wants to develop trust and project better image in the public, it cannot afford to resist change. And greater transparency and accountability in the police functioning are political attributes of good governance. However, systemic change also carries huge political risk if not managed without adequate preparations. Gahlot is aware of this risk as he has remarked that free registration of cases would result in sudden increase in number of FIRs. Notwithstanding the spurt in crime rates, as informed by the expanding wave of FIRs registered in the state during the last one year, the practice of mandatory registration of cases must be continued. The primary motive behind mandatory registration of FIR is to ensure quick response to all crimes and attempts to collect evidence, two key elements of a credible investigation and trial. Although the intention is laudable, the implementation would need to be watched carefully. Extracted with edits from: https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/blogs/et-commentary/free-registration-of-fir-towards-good-governance/ by the Economic Times, 30 January 2020 1. According to the author, India is likely to have lower crime statistics because-(a) India is a crime free country(b) All Indian states have low crime rates (c) Crime is underreported in India(d) None of the above 2. The passage suggests that registration of FIR is necessary in cases of - (a) All offences(b) Offences which are cognizable as per opinion of the police(c) Offences which are cognizable as per law(d) All non-cognizable offences 3. The author has used the term "free registration" to mean - (a) registration of cases without payment of money(b) compulsory registration of cases by police(c) compulsory registration of cases by the judiciary(d) None of the above Passage II Chief Justice JS Khehar has expressed concern over the media trial of suspects in any case and hinted that the Supreme Court would draw the line on how much policemen can tell the media during the pre-trial, investigation stage as reportage sometimes undermines free and fair trial.
The proposed guidelines, in line with an existing central government advisory, will decide whether policemen can parade the accused before cameras, whether their identities can be revealed, etc.
A bench, comprising CJI Khehar and Justice NV Ramana, agreed with a suggestion by amicus curiae Gopal Shankarnarayan that there be some norms on police briefings for the media.
“Reputation of a person is very important. People may be arrested… If they are shown on electronic media, their reputation is smeared forever, even though they may be acquitted later,” CJI Khehar observed. The court was dealing with a host of petitions calling for guidelines for the police or investigating agencies briefing the media about any ongoing investigation. The petitions have been pending since 1999.In another case, a Constitution bench had already ruled that if any accused faces a smear campaign during trial which may prejudice his case, he would be free to approach the trial court to postpone the reporting of an order. Activist lawyer Prashant Bhushan argued that releasing the names of suspects even before the FIR was filed in some cases in press statements results in pre-judging a case. Often the reputation of totally innocent people are smeared beyond repair. “This not only causes serious harm to the reputation of the person but also affects the trial,” he said. The CJI directed the central government and all interested parties such as state governments, the Press Council of India, NHRC etc to submit their views through a questionnaire prepared by the amicus curiae which would decide whether an accused can be paraded before the media, whether his identity can be revealed or the evidence against him played out live on TV, etc.
The court will base its orders on the responses of all stakeholders and revise the existing central government advisory to investigative agencies on the dos and don’ts of media briefings by police.
This would decide how much they can reveal to the press without compromising the possibility of upsetting the fundamental premise of our criminal justice system –– that a person is innocent until proven guilty. Extracted with edits from: https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/supreme-court-hints-at-end-to-media-trial/articleshow/57028827.cms by the Economic Times, 08 February 2017 1. The above passage indicates that media trial directly harms-(a) the life of a person(b) the reputation of a person(c) the property of a person(d) None of the above 2. For framing guidelines regulating media trial, Supreme Court adopted the process of- (a) judicial review (b) stakeholder consultation (c) both (a) and (b) (d) None of the above 3. The above passage indicates that the role of "amicus curiae" is to- (a) assist the court in process of adjudication (b) dictate the court as to what orders it must pass (c) regulate the functioning of the court(d) None of the above
Answer key with explanations Passage IQuestion 1 - Option (c) is the correct answer.Explanation - Paragraph 1 of the passage mentions that underreporting of cases distorts the crime scenario in India. Question 2 - Option (c) is the correct answer. Explanation - Paragraph 3 of the passage indicates that registration of FIR is necessary in cases of offences cognizable as per law. Question 3 - Option (b) is the correct answer. Explanation - A plain reading of the passage indicates that the author has used the term "free registration" to mean compulsory registration of cases by the police. Passage IIQuestion 1 - Option (b) is the correct answer. Explanation - Paragraph 3 of the passage indicates that media trial directly harms the reputation of a person. Question 2 - Option (c) is the correct answer. Explanation - The Supreme Court shall revise the existing government advisory by passing orders in a pending case which is essentially the process of judicial review. Since it has also decided to obtain views of all interested parties before passing orders, it has also adopted process of stakeholder consultation. Question 3 - Option (a) is the correct answer. Explanation - Paragraph 2 of the passage indicates that role of amicus curiae is to assist the court. (function( $ ) { //footnotes $('.defaultNote').children(":first").css('cursor', 'pointer'); $('.defaultNote').children(":first").click(function(){ var gotoID = '#' + $(this).parent().attr('id'); $('html, body').animate( { scrollTop: $('a[href="' + gotoID + '"]').offset().top - 60, }, 250, 'linear' ) }); }(jQuery)); var numFormat = ",."; (function( $ ) { "use strict"; //do some cleaning on load var sortCells = $('td[data-sorting], th[data-sorting]'); sortCells.each(function(){ var first = $(this).text().trim().charAt(0); if (first == '@'){ var oldHTML = $(this).html(); var newHTML = oldHTML.replace('@', ''); $(this).html(newHTML); } }); function sortingTable(node, pos, ordBy){ var rows = node.children('tbody').children('tr').get(); rows.sort(function(a, b) { var X = $(a).children('td').eq(pos).text().toUpperCase(); var Y = $(b).children('td').eq(pos).text().toUpperCase(); if (numFormat != '.,'){ //we are dealing with a different locale and we need to do some //transformation in numbers X = convert2number(X); Y = convert2number(Y); } else { X = X.replace(/,/g, '').replace(/ /g, ''); Y = Y.replace(/,/g, '').replace(/ /g, ''); } var currencies = ['$', '¥', '£', '€']; var arrayLength = currencies.length; var XX = X; var YY = Y; for (var i = 0; i < arrayLength; i++) { XX = XX.replace(currencies[i], ''); YY = YY.replace(currencies[i], ''); } if (!isNaN(XX) && !isNaN(YY)){ var floatXX = parseFloat(XX); var floatYY = parseFloat(YY); return -(floatYY-floatXX) * ordBy; } else if (!isNaN(XX) && isNaN(YY)){ return -1 * ordBy; } else if (isNaN(XX) && !isNaN(YY)){ return ordBy; } else { if(X < Y) { return -1 * ordBy; } if(X > Y) { return 1 * ordBy; } return 0; } }); $.each(rows, function(index, row) { node.children('tbody').append(row); }); } function removeTableCellDecoration() { $("td[data-sorting], th[data-sorting]").removeClass('sortDecorator'); } //unbind the click event just in case we are loading more than one document $("td[data-sorting], th[data-sorting]").off('click'); $("td[data-sorting], th[data-sorting]").click(function(){ removeTableCellDecoration(); $(this).addClass('sortDecorator'); //get desired ordering var ordering = $(this).attr('data-sortOrdering'); if (ordering == 'ASC'){ var ordBy = -1; $(this).attr('data-sortOrdering', 'DESC'); } else { var ordBy = 1; $(this).attr('data-sortOrdering', 'ASC'); } var cellPosition = $(this).prevAll().length; var table = $(this).parents('table:first'); sortingTable(table, cellPosition, ordBy); }); function convert2number(str) { str = str.trim(); if (str.match(/^\d+/)) { //we have to take special care when the thousand separators are '.' var result_0 = str.replace(/\./g, '_@_'); var result_1 = result_0.replace(window.numFormat[0], '.'); var result = result_1.replace(/_@_/g, ''); result .replace(/ /g, ''); return result; } else { return str; } } }(jQuery));
The proposed guidelines, in line with an existing central government advisory, will decide whether policemen can parade the accused before cameras, whether their identities can be revealed, etc.
A bench, comprising CJI Khehar and Justice NV Ramana, agreed with a suggestion by amicus curiae Gopal Shankarnarayan that there be some norms on police briefings for the media.
“Reputation of a person is very important. People may be arrested… If they are shown on electronic media, their reputation is smeared forever, even though they may be acquitted later,” CJI Khehar observed. The court was dealing with a host of petitions calling for guidelines for the police or investigating agencies briefing the media about any ongoing investigation. The petitions have been pending since 1999.In another case, a Constitution bench had already ruled that if any accused faces a smear campaign during trial which may prejudice his case, he would be free to approach the trial court to postpone the reporting of an order. Activist lawyer Prashant Bhushan argued that releasing the names of suspects even before the FIR was filed in some cases in press statements results in pre-judging a case. Often the reputation of totally innocent people are smeared beyond repair. “This not only causes serious harm to the reputation of the person but also affects the trial,” he said. The CJI directed the central government and all interested parties such as state governments, the Press Council of India, NHRC etc to submit their views through a questionnaire prepared by the amicus curiae which would decide whether an accused can be paraded before the media, whether his identity can be revealed or the evidence against him played out live on TV, etc.
The court will base its orders on the responses of all stakeholders and revise the existing central government advisory to investigative agencies on the dos and don’ts of media briefings by police.
This would decide how much they can reveal to the press without compromising the possibility of upsetting the fundamental premise of our criminal justice system –– that a person is innocent until proven guilty. Extracted with edits from: https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/supreme-court-hints-at-end-to-media-trial/articleshow/57028827.cms by the Economic Times, 08 February 2017 1. The above passage indicates that media trial directly harms-(a) the life of a person(b) the reputation of a person(c) the property of a person(d) None of the above 2. For framing guidelines regulating media trial, Supreme Court adopted the process of- (a) judicial review (b) stakeholder consultation (c) both (a) and (b) (d) None of the above 3. The above passage indicates that the role of "amicus curiae" is to- (a) assist the court in process of adjudication (b) dictate the court as to what orders it must pass (c) regulate the functioning of the court(d) None of the above
Answer key with explanations Passage IQuestion 1 - Option (c) is the correct answer.Explanation - Paragraph 1 of the passage mentions that underreporting of cases distorts the crime scenario in India. Question 2 - Option (c) is the correct answer. Explanation - Paragraph 3 of the passage indicates that registration of FIR is necessary in cases of offences cognizable as per law. Question 3 - Option (b) is the correct answer. Explanation - A plain reading of the passage indicates that the author has used the term "free registration" to mean compulsory registration of cases by the police. Passage IIQuestion 1 - Option (b) is the correct answer. Explanation - Paragraph 3 of the passage indicates that media trial directly harms the reputation of a person. Question 2 - Option (c) is the correct answer. Explanation - The Supreme Court shall revise the existing government advisory by passing orders in a pending case which is essentially the process of judicial review. Since it has also decided to obtain views of all interested parties before passing orders, it has also adopted process of stakeholder consultation. Question 3 - Option (a) is the correct answer. Explanation - Paragraph 2 of the passage indicates that role of amicus curiae is to assist the court. (function( $ ) { //footnotes $('.defaultNote').children(":first").css('cursor', 'pointer'); $('.defaultNote').children(":first").click(function(){ var gotoID = '#' + $(this).parent().attr('id'); $('html, body').animate( { scrollTop: $('a[href="' + gotoID + '"]').offset().top - 60, }, 250, 'linear' ) }); }(jQuery)); var numFormat = ",."; (function( $ ) { "use strict"; //do some cleaning on load var sortCells = $('td[data-sorting], th[data-sorting]'); sortCells.each(function(){ var first = $(this).text().trim().charAt(0); if (first == '@'){ var oldHTML = $(this).html(); var newHTML = oldHTML.replace('@', ''); $(this).html(newHTML); } }); function sortingTable(node, pos, ordBy){ var rows = node.children('tbody').children('tr').get(); rows.sort(function(a, b) { var X = $(a).children('td').eq(pos).text().toUpperCase(); var Y = $(b).children('td').eq(pos).text().toUpperCase(); if (numFormat != '.,'){ //we are dealing with a different locale and we need to do some //transformation in numbers X = convert2number(X); Y = convert2number(Y); } else { X = X.replace(/,/g, '').replace(/ /g, ''); Y = Y.replace(/,/g, '').replace(/ /g, ''); } var currencies = ['$', '¥', '£', '€']; var arrayLength = currencies.length; var XX = X; var YY = Y; for (var i = 0; i < arrayLength; i++) { XX = XX.replace(currencies[i], ''); YY = YY.replace(currencies[i], ''); } if (!isNaN(XX) && !isNaN(YY)){ var floatXX = parseFloat(XX); var floatYY = parseFloat(YY); return -(floatYY-floatXX) * ordBy; } else if (!isNaN(XX) && isNaN(YY)){ return -1 * ordBy; } else if (isNaN(XX) && !isNaN(YY)){ return ordBy; } else { if(X < Y) { return -1 * ordBy; } if(X > Y) { return 1 * ordBy; } return 0; } }); $.each(rows, function(index, row) { node.children('tbody').append(row); }); } function removeTableCellDecoration() { $("td[data-sorting], th[data-sorting]").removeClass('sortDecorator'); } //unbind the click event just in case we are loading more than one document $("td[data-sorting], th[data-sorting]").off('click'); $("td[data-sorting], th[data-sorting]").click(function(){ removeTableCellDecoration(); $(this).addClass('sortDecorator'); //get desired ordering var ordering = $(this).attr('data-sortOrdering'); if (ordering == 'ASC'){ var ordBy = -1; $(this).attr('data-sortOrdering', 'DESC'); } else { var ordBy = 1; $(this).attr('data-sortOrdering', 'ASC'); } var cellPosition = $(this).prevAll().length; var table = $(this).parents('table:first'); sortingTable(table, cellPosition, ordBy); }); function convert2number(str) { str = str.trim(); if (str.match(/^\d+/)) { //we have to take special care when the thousand separators are '.' var result_0 = str.replace(/\./g, '_@_'); var result_1 = result_0.replace(window.numFormat[0], '.'); var result = result_1.replace(/_@_/g, ''); result .replace(/ /g, ''); return result; } else { return str; } } }(jQuery));
Subscribe for updates
Join 10,000+ subscribers.
AD
Aditya Anand
Contributing author
Have a doubt about this?Ask Doubts
